Home

About us

Contact

Procedures

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO

Ear, Nose, and Throat

2203 45th St Ste B , Highland, IN

(219) 836-4820

Repuscore

0%

8 Reviews

About me

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO is a Otolaryngology (Ear, Nose & Throat) Specialist in Highland, IN and has over 20 years of experience in the medical field. Dr. Cataldi has more experience with Upper Respiratory Conditions, Ear, Nose, and Throat Surgery, and Otologic Care than other specialists in her area. She graduated from Chicago College Of Osteopathic Medicine Of Midwestern University, Midwestern University medical school in 2000. She is affiliated with medical facilities Methodist Hospitals - Northlake Campus and St. Catherine Hospital. She is accepting new patients. Be sure to call ahead with Dr. Cataldi to book an appointment.

Repuscore Overview

Patient’s experience of staff, facilities and outcome

0%

What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

Patients have reviewed this doctor consistently positive about their staff, their facilities and/or are happy with their results.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

This doctor may have a lack of reviews, the reviews themselves are poor quality or they are unhappy about their experience.

Background & credentials

0%

What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

This doctor is more likely to be board certified, doesn’t have any malpractics, relies on many years of experience and went to a top medical school.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

Very low scores can indicate that this doctor may have evidence of board actions or malpractice or is less likely to be board certified.

Personality

0%

What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

We score a range of characteristics of doctors that are perceived positive such as honesty, professional and things like bedside manner.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

This doctor may have limited amount of reviews or the reviews themselves are not very descriptive.

Recommendations

0%

What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

This doctor is likely to have many patient recommending him or her.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

A very low score can mean that patients are not recommending this doctor, but more commonly people don’t recommend means that they fail to report this in their reviews.

Overview

Reviews

Write a review

Dr. Bethany Cataldi, DO - Reviews

Dave B. – Dec 04, 2019

Patient

Dr Cataldi cured my, long lasting, nagging sinus condition and cough! In addition some precancerous growths were removed from my face and back. The results were pretty amazing. The staff is always friendly and helpful I highly recommend Dr Cataldi.

James N. – Aug 28, 2019

Patient

A WONDERFUL LIFE SAVING CARING SURGEON! Dr. Cataldi successfully diagnosed and treated my throat cancer that another doctor failed to diagnose. She took the time to discuss with me all the pros and cons of the treatment (believe me- it was not an easy time for me and my family) and in the end I'm alive today and cancer-free when I could have met the Maker. GOD BLESS YOU DR. BETHANY!

2 Disgusted – Aug 24, 2019

Patient

Terrible. She removed a mass in my partner's neck but didn't bother to stay for post-op direction even though I was waiting. No anti-inflamatory medication or antibiotics prescribed until swelling became apparent and he had to go back. Then, we find out she left part of the mass still in the throat. She also treated his deviated septum and again did not explain what complications could arise BECAUSE SHE BUGGED OUT IMMEDIATELY after the surgery. Problems then arose because his nose became extremely dry and uncomfortable. Only then did she prescribe spray to alleviate the problem. Seems sloppy and incompetent with little regard to post-op follow-up care. Would not take my cat to her. Would give a 0 rating if available.

5 2 May 16, 2019

Patient

Horrible experience!! I would NEVER recommend!! Could care less about the patient. She only has surgery privileges 1 time a month at the 2 hospitals she works with. (St. Catherine’s and Broadway Methodist.) Called for a month before I found that out. Paid $20 weeks ago for a copy of my daughters scan and test results which they STILL HAVEN’T done it. She was only seen once & had the CT scan right there at the same time. They tell you it could take 30 days. Serious?? That’s just laziness. Horrible service, communication and bedside manor. When I finally spoke with Dr. Cataldi, she told me “good luck finding a doctor that will do a tonsillectomy and adenoids outpatient at a hospital.” We set up an appointment with a fabulous doctor who actually has plenty of surgical privileges and got her in for surgery within 2 weeks. So glad we went somewhere else that actually cares!!

1 Karen Conner in Michigan City , IN – Sep 18, 2018

Patient

I was having dental inssues that created a major infection in my jaw. For 8 weeks I could not get this resolved . My dentists were at a loss! They tried but it got worse with the most horrendous pain that would not subside . I made appt. with Dr. Cataldi and she saw me immediately ! Did a CT scan and showed me the infection which was serious !! She prescribed a combo of anti Biotics, steroids and pain meds . In a matter of 10 days the infection was gone . She really handled this perfectly

6 Gary J in Hammond, IN – Apr 13, 2017

Patient

Dr. Cataldi is the best and kindest ENT in the area. She listens to her patients like we are family. At every visit we have had the opportunity to take the time to discuss our ear nose and throat issues and she will take the time needed to listen diagnose and treat. Highly recommended!!!!!

12 1 Crown Point, IN – Mar 13, 2017

Patient

I've never had a Dr. That cared less than Bethany Cataldi

6 Mary A in Highland, IN – Nov 04, 2016

Patient

Dr. Cataldi helped me breathe again!! She is a compassionate and vibrant surgeon who has improved my life and my husband's life more than we can put into words.