About us



Dr. Matthew Kilgo, MD

Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery

999 Franklin Ave , Garden City, NY




28 Reviews

About me

Dr. Matthew Kilgo, MD is a Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery Specialist in Garden City, NY and has over 27 years of experience in the medical field. Dr. Kilgo has more experience with Breast Surgery than other specialists in his area. He graduated from University Of Chicago medical school in 1993. He is affiliated with medical facilities such as Mercy Medical Center and Nassau University Medical Center. He is accepting new patients and has indicated that he accepts telehealth appointments. Be sure to call ahead with Dr. Kilgo to book an appointment.

Repuscore Overview

Patient’s experience of staff, facilities and outcome


What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

Patients have reviewed this doctor consistently positive about their staff, their facilities and/or are happy with their results.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

This doctor may have a lack of reviews, the reviews themselves are poor quality or they are unhappy about their experience.

Background & credentials


What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

This doctor is more likely to be board certified, doesn’t have any malpractics, relies on many years of experience and went to a top medical school.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

Very low scores can indicate that this doctor may have evidence of board actions or malpractice or is less likely to be board certified.



What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

We score a range of characteristics of doctors that are perceived positive such as honesty, professional and things like bedside manner.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

This doctor may have limited amount of reviews or the reviews themselves are not very descriptive.



What a higher score can indicate (>75%):

This doctor is likely to have many patient recommending him or her.

What a lower score can indicate (<55%):

A very low score can mean that patients are not recommending this doctor, but more commonly people don’t recommend means that they fail to report this in their reviews.



Write a review

Dr. Matthew Kilgo, MD - Reviews

Jun 18, 2020


I was impressed with Dr. Kilgo. He is patient, extremely detailed and knowledgeable and his caring manner put me at ease. I could immediately tell he was a caring and excellent doctor. I was referred to him by my surgeon for another medical issue and Dr. Kilgo explained how I did not need another unrelated cosmetic procedure and took an interest in my abdominal surgery. I know that I will return to him for breast surgery.

May 03, 2020


it was greate

Barbara, Garden City – Apr 08, 2020


This was a post-surgery follow-up. Dr. Kilgo's PA, Bobby, was very helpful and answered all my questions putting me at ease. Dr. Kilgo was able to come in which was great. His bedside manner is exactly what I need...informative and calming. So happy that my breast surgeon recommended him! The surgery seems to have been successful and looking forward to being totally healed!! Thank you Dr. Kilgo!

4 Sharon I. – Oct 11, 2019


Dr. Kilgo and his team and the staff are fantastic and talented! Would highly recommend!

4 Kierah – Sep 20, 2019


Dr. Kilgo and his team were beyond amazing! My surgery went so smoothly and I can’t wait to see my great results once I’m healed. Great bedside manner, everyone is so kind and helpful. I’m so glad I chose LIPSG, do not regret it one bit!

2 Linda C – Sep 18, 2019


I have been treated by Dr Kilgo and his PA Bobby for the past year since my mastectomy From the first visit I felt very confident that everything would be fine. He explained my options thoroughly and answered any questions I had. I found both Dr Kilgo and Bobby to be very kind and caring and would recommend them to others

4 Jennifer Nevill in Rockville Centre, NY – Jun 06, 2019


Dr. Kilgo performed my bilateral mastectomy and I knew I was in the best hands. He made me feel at ease at my pre-surgical appointment and the follow up visits. He is extremely knowledgable in the area of breast reconstruction and I know I made the right decision with Dr. Kilgo. Bobby Matthews, his PA was extremely nice and knowledgeable as well and the nurses and office staff are very welcoming and compassionate. I highly recommend Dr. Kilgo.

2 May 09, 2019


Breast reconstruction

T. Henderson in Brooklyn, NY – Dec 20, 2018


Dr. Kilgo and his team at Long Island Plastic Surgical Group are AMAZING!!!. Dr. Kilgo performed my bilateral mastectomy with reconstruction and people are floored when they find out I'm a breast cancer survivor & these beauties are implants. Other doctors are amazed and shocked to hear that they are implants. All agree that my plastic surgeon did an amazing job. When the doctors & nurses at Winthrop ask who performed my surgery, I say Dr Kilgo.. they all say his work is great. Grateful for him.

D Lazzara – Aug 28, 2018


Dr. Kilgo was recommended to me by my doctor. Pre-surgery he answered all my questions and put my mind at ease. I had my surgery 3 weeks ago and am very happy with the results. Excellent doctor and a great staff! I have already recommended him to two family members.

EMD in Long Beach, NY – Aug 23, 2018


For my most recent appointment, a breast reconstruction post-op visit, I actually saw Bobby Matthews, Dr. Kilgo's PA. It is common for Bobby to handle follow-up visits & some treatments. Dr. Kilgo clearly trusts him. Bobby is always informative, helpful, professional & friendly, as he was on Aug 21st. I left knowing my healing was going well, what I should/should not do, what the next steps in my reconstruction will be & when they can occur. I was very happy with the care that Bobby provided.

Maria Xenios in NY – Aug 13, 2018


Love everyone in this office. Everyone is so nice and helpful and friendly makes you feel so comfortable when you are there.

Nancy U. in Smithtown, NY – Jul 08, 2018


Due to Stage One Invasive Ductal Cell Carcinoma in my right breast, I ultimately had a bilateral mastectomy. Dr. Kilgo was there for the immediate reconstruction by inserting tissue expanders and later for their removal as well as for the insertion of my implants and fat grafting. He is an extremely knowledgeable, highly skilled plastic surgeon. He gave me back what cancer robbed from me. He even made me look better than I did before. I will be forever grateful for his talent and expertise.

Iris Cales in Hicksville – Jul 08, 2018


He is a knowledgeable and very easy to understand.Great bed manners staff is amicable and compassionate.I will defenetly recomend Dr Kilgo.

Lisa in New York – Apr 10, 2018


Dr. Kilgo is an amazing surgeon. I am blessed to have found him and would recommend him to anyone who is looking for a surgeon who is bright, confident, knowledgeable and so caring of his patients. There are not enough words to describe my every experience with him.

Mar 22, 2018


Very knowledgeable and patient.

Mar 18, 2018


Very happy to have found Dr Kilgo and LIPSG. He is an excellent doctor, very reassuring and I'm so happy with my outcome. His PA and nurses are great and the staff at LIPSG are helpful and so nice. Excellent practice, I'd highly recommend.

J. Friedrich in Mt. Sinai – Mar 03, 2018


Dr. Kilgo (and his team)are incredible. My experience with them has been wonderful. They are informative, supportive, understanding and my results have exceeded my expectations. I would suggest to anyone contemplating plastic surgery, consulting with Dr. Kilgo is a must!

Jan 27, 2018


Dr Kilgo was recommended by my internist, and I'm so glad. I had a breast reduction a month ago and the whole process has been wonderful. He is an excellent surgeon with a caring staff. I felt cared for and confident throughout the process. Highly recommend!!

1 Hempstead, NY – Dec 02, 2017


Dr. Kilgo amazing &has a fantastic team.He & his team understand the sensitivity,emotional journey,&restoration of beauty someone w/Breast Cancer needs.I’m a young StageFourBreastCancerSurvivor, under 40,&I’ve been thru so much.Every appointment’s a positive one,filled w/smiles,care,understanding.I had breast expanders & recent breast reconstruction w/Dr. Kilgo.He gave back what cancer took & I feel like myself. He’s caring, kind, answers every question & has a vision for beauty when he works.

1 Glen Head, NY – Jun 13, 2017


I would continue to and have recommended Dr Kilgo to anyone. He is professional, knowledgeable, and gentle.

3 Jackelyn D. in Copiague, NY – Feb 08, 2017


Dr. Kilgo, in my opinion is the very best Doctor in the world. He truly cares about you, and gives you advice on the perfect treatments for breast augmentation. I am absolutely thrilled with my results, and will continue seeing him forever. I feel So good after 2 weeks of my surgery. He, and his...Read More

1 Plainview, NY – Jan 13, 2017


Doctor Kilgo is the best plastic surgeon. I had my breast augmentation 2 months ago. I am very pleased with the results. I can't wait for him to do my tummy tuck.

Mallory T in West Babylon, NY – Nov 29, 2016


Dr. Kilgo is a gifted surgeon. He made me feel whole again after I had 3 beautiful children! His staff were wonderful, as well as his PA Bobby who is wonderful! Cant thank these doctors and nurses enough! They are highly recommended.

Michael F. in Long Island, NY – Oct 02, 2016


Dr. Kilgo treated my condition with professionalism & sensitivity to my needs. Any prospective patient who is considering plastic surgery to live life more comfortably, would greatly benefit seeking Dr. Kilgo as his/her physician of choice. -- Michael F., Long Island, NY

1 Heather R. in Long Beach NY – Sep 19, 2016


Dr. Kilgo did breast reconstruction for me after breast cancer , and after another PS mutilated my initial reconstruction. I can't say enough good things about him and his staff. Precise, professional and efficient. I would recommend him and his support staff in a heartbeat

1 Lizabeth Evans in East Northport, NY – Jul 07, 2016


We cannot say enough about Dr. Matthew S. Kilgo! When my sister was diagnosed with genetic Braca I breast cancer, he did a wonderful job making her whole again. Our 20-something year old daughter underwent prophylactic breast removal, since she too had the gene, and we had lost family members to...Read More

7 D.S in Shirley, NY – May 18, 2016


NEVER will I recommend this Dr. He basically will deny a procedure because you do not fall under a certain textbook BMI regardless of the benefits of procedure. Will actually see you for the consult to tell you this to your face and refer you to a bariatric surgery instead.